Schrodinger's Tritone Sub

ii-V7-I (drop 2 and 3)


I was practicing my major ii-V-I's (drop 2 and 3) as usual when I noticed something interesting... First of all, this is a standard progression that goes Dminor7 - G7 - CMajor7.







How it normally sounds: 



On a specific voicing, 1-3-7-5, of the minor-7 chord, it feels natural to go to a dominant flat-5 chord instead of the vanilla V7.

ii-V7b5-I (drop 2 and 3)


In the key of C, this would be D-F-C-A going to Db-F-B-G, as shown on the left. Accidentally playing this progression, I wasn't offended because it's a cool sound. Observe the chromatic descending line in the bass.







Same progression, but with a V7b5:



ii-V7b5-bVM7

As I resolved the dominant chord, my fingers, by their own agency, proceeded to play a Gb-Maj7 instead of CMaj7. Voiced Db-F-Bb-Gb, this chord is a tritone away from the tonic, but it doesn't sound bad at all. In fact, if I wasn't expecting to hear a C-Maj7, it'd be a completely normal resolution. This progression can also be thought of as a ii-V in Gb Major, but with a tritone substitution on the ii chord.






ii-Vb5 in C, but I resolve to Gb Major




But the real question is, is this dominant sound G7 flat-5 or a Db7 flat-5? The answer is yes. When you hear this sonority, you can conclude that it is simultaneously a tritone sub and not a tritone sub. It is Schrodinger's Tritone Sub.

The justification for this is that any Dominant flat-5 chord is a tritone sub of itself. If we layout the notes in ascending order G-B-Db-F, then plane the same shape a tritone up, we get Db-F-G-B. Same notes, exact same intervals! For this reason, a Dominant flat-5 only has 12 potential voicings, as opposed to the 24 that the standard 7th chords contain.



Now observe the same progression, but a tritone away, in the key of Gb:


ii-V7-I in Gb




ii-Vb5-I in Gb


ii-Vb in Gb, but resolve to C



It's really important to observe that the keys of C and Gb contain the same Dominant flat-5 chord and thus can resolve to either key.

Now try it on your guitar. Play this Db7 flat 5 voicing on the middle 4 strings.








Then, move every finger up exactly 6 frets...


Now you have G7 flat 5. Cool! This is the same sound as a french augmented 6th, as the classical nomenclature dictates. How does it work? Well, the chord contains 2 tritones. G-Db and B-F. And when you move a tritone up by a tritone, you get another tritone. It's similar to how a fully diminished chord may be moved up by either a minor third or tritone and maintain the same chord tones.



But why is it called Schrodinger's Tritone Sub? Well, it's simple. The thought experiment Schrodinger's Cat concludes that if a cat is in a box and you can't see whether or not it's alive, you must assume it's both dead and alive at the same time. In this case, the Dominant flat-5 chord is the dead/alive status of the cat, the tonic chord is the box, and it's resolution is the equivalent of opening up the box to get an answer.

This chord relationship allows one to modulate a tritone away at whim and thus thwart the listener's expectations. How do you like to use Dominant flat-5 chords? Let me know in the comments!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Drop Voicings Part 1: Introduction

Image
In part 1 of this article, we will identify a challenge that is inherent to the guitar and suggest a solution: Drop Voicings. Then we will go into depth about the most common example: Drop-2.  In part 2, we will dissect all the types of drop voicings. In part 3, we will learn a practical exercise that will incorporate the drop voicings into your harmonic vocabulary.  If you are curious about what "Drop-2" or "Drop-3" means, this article is for you. If you do know what those terms mean, you might find some additional insight here. To start, here are the four inversions of a C Major 7 chord:   Fig 1: Close Voicings These are called the "close voicings" because the notes are as close together as possible. If you look at the top and bottom notes of each inversion, you'll find that the notes span an interval less than an octave. For example, root position has the interval C-B, which is a Major 7th. 1st inversion has the interval E-C, which is a minor 6th. T
Read more

The Secrets of the Diminished Scale that Theory Professors Don't Want You to Know About

Image
The diminished, also known as the "Octatonic" scale is known for its symmetry which is achieved by a strict alternation of half-step, whole-step, half-step, whole-step etc. G diminished scale One of the many fascinating facts about the diminished scale is its eight tones can be organized into two fully diminished 7th chords, a half step away. The two diminished chords that comprise the octatonic scale On top of that, if we invert any diminished 7th chord, we get the exact same intervals of the original chord, which results as the same shape on guitar shifted up three frets. For example, the G diminished chord above becomes B-flat diminished. B-flat diminished 7th With these two facts in mind, it can be extrapolated that any octatonic scale may be harmonized with nothing but diminished chords, as such: Fig 4: Harmonized G Octatonic Scale Yet this scale hides much more than just diminished chords. It has minor 7th, dominant 7th, major 7 sus4 #11, an
Read more

The Diminished Scale Is A Pathway To Many Substitutions Some Consider To Be Unnatural

Image
Many guitarists are familiar with the classic ii-V-I progression. Figure 1: ii-V-I It's a tried and true sequence of chords, but it can get a bit... vanilla. One way of spicing it up is borrowing the Vb9 chord from harmonic minor. Figure 2: ii-Vb9-I If you play Figure 2  on your guitar, you'll notice that the second chord is simply a fully diminished 7th chord. This is an easy way of voicing a G7-flat 9 chord on guitar without playing the root. D is the fifth, A-flat is the flat 9, B is the third, and F is the seventh. Playing this chord is as easy as raising the root of the vanilla V7 voicing. Don't forget that A-flat is the flat 9. Since a diminished 7th chord may be spelled with any of the four tones as the root, why can't we consider any of these four tones to be the flat 9? For instance, if F  is the flat 9, this is an E7 flat 9 chord. If B is the flat 9, this is a Bb7-flat 9. If D  is the flat 9, this is a Db7 flat 9. To take it a step farther
Read more